!Discussion: What if this and What if that happened?

[weber_dubois22]

(c)finalcaps.tumblr.com

Despite the torrid history of Video Game Adaptation's (helmed by their creators or otherwise noted), do you think, if Spirits Within had been produced and released during the advancement of Computer Generated films and the 3D/IMAX craze that the movie would be any better received, or worse given the implications attached to the latter two categories above and so forth?

Comments

[hana-ginkawa.livejournal.com]

I think that it would have been better received. However, the "Final Fantasy" part of the name would have to have been dropped, with a tagline saying "From the creators of Final Fantasy" instead, because I think a lot of people were disappointed that it wasn't connected with any of the previous games. The same would have been true had it been released at that same time.

[liedownlovely.livejournal.com]

+1